Oak or Plane for a Table Top
Oak is harder and darker with age, plane is paler and more figured. Which suits which room.
These two get compared because they occupy the same ground: pale European hardwoods that cost less than walnut. They are not interchangeable.
The comparison in one table
| Oak | Plane | |
|---|---|---|
| Colour new | Pale blond to light honey | Cream to pinkish light brown |
| Colour in ten years | Noticeably ambered, mid honey brown | Slightly warmed, still pale |
| Figure | Cathedral grain, occasional broad silver ray fleck | Dense fine ray fleck across the whole face |
| Hardness | Harder | Softer, dents more readily |
| Grain texture | Ring porous, open pores you can feel | Finer and more even, smoother to the touch |
| Chemistry | Tannin reacts with iron and water, black stains | No significant reactivity |
| Spalting | Uncommon in stock | Common, and often attractive |
| Durability in damp | Good | Poor. An indoor timber. |
| Slab sizes here | 200 to 300 cm, 85 to 140 cm wide | 240 to 330 cm, 93 to 130 cm wide |
| Price | Mid | Lowest of the three species |
Pick oak if
- The surface will take punishment. Kitchen island, bar, family dining table, hallway bench. Hardness is the deciding factor and oak has it.
- Water is involved. Not that oak is waterproof, but it is the better of the two around a sink: oak kitchen island tops.
- You want the table to warm up over the years rather than stay as it is.
- You like the ray fleck as a feature rather than as a texture, meaning occasional bold flashes rather than an all-over speckle.
Pick plane if
- You need length. Plane reaches 330 cm here, oak stops at 300 cm, and plane is cheaper per metre: plane dining tables.
- The room is dark and you want a surface that lifts it and stays pale.
- You want the detailed figure. Plane's speckle is the most consistently figured surface of the three.
- Budget is the constraint. It is the way into a big solid top for the least money.
Three differences that decide most cases
- The colour journey. Oak gets warmer every year. Plane barely moves. If you are matching an existing oak floor or oak kitchen, bear in mind that a new oak top will be paler than the aged oak around it for the first few years and then catch up. Plane will not catch up because it is not going the same way.
- What you feel. Oak's open pores are noticeable under the hand. On a dining table that is texture. On a desk or a bar where forearms rest all evening, some people prefer plane's finer surface: an oak slab desk.
- Iron and water. Oak's tannin reaction is a real maintenance consideration in a hallway or a kitchen. Plane has no equivalent problem.
Where neither is the right answer
If the top will be outdoors, neither of these, and plane least of all. Both are specified and dried here as interior timbers at 8 to 10 percent moisture, and an interior slab outdoors will move hard, check and grey: kiln dried or air dried.
If the room wants a dark table, neither, because staining a pale wood dark rarely matches the depth of walnut: walnut or oak for a dining table.
Finishing: one decision each
- Oak: fill the pores or leave them open, and clear oil or pigmented. A clear oil ambers oak noticeably on the first coat.
- Plane: clear or white pigment. A white pigmented hardwax oil keeps plane deliberately pale and hides handling marks better on cream wood.
Both are covered in hardwax oil, lacquer or epoxy.
The gap is visible in our own stock: the slab price index puts plane at the bottom of the range per square metre and walnut at the top, with oak between them.
Common questions
Is plane a real hardwood?
Yes. Hardwood is a botanical classification, not a measure of hardness. Plane is a broadleaf hardwood that is softer than oak, as walnut is.
Why is plane called lacewood?
It is a trade name used when the cut shows the ray figure strongly, from the lace-like pattern. Different markets apply it to different species, so check what tree is actually being sold.
Will spalted plane keep spreading?
No. Kiln drying kills the fungus, so the pattern is fixed. What matters is whether the spalted wood is sound rather than soft.
Which is better for a long bench?
Plane for length and price, oak for hardness on a seat that gets daily use. Both need the thickness and span sorted: how far a slab can span unsupported.