Z-Clips, Figure-Eight Fasteners and Slotted Holes
The three common fastener types compared, with where each belongs on a slab and how many to use.
A solid top changes width with the seasons. Every fastening method is judged on one question: does it hold the top down while letting it get wider and narrower. Three answers are in common use and they are not interchangeable.
The movement you are designing for
Across the grain, a wide slab in a European house moves measurably between a damp summer and a dry heated winter. On a 90 cm wide oak top, expect something in the region of 5 to 10 mm of total seasonal change, more in a house with big humidity swings and less in a controlled one. Along its length the movement is negligible.
That is the whole design problem. Hold the top firmly in one direction, let it slide in the other. The background is in seasonal movement and humidity.
The three options
| Slotted holes | Figure-eight fasteners | Z-clips | |
|---|---|---|---|
| How it works | Screw slides along a slot in the base | Steel plate pivots as the top moves | Clip slides in a groove in the apron |
| Needs in the base | Slots milled in the steel or rail | A shallow recess at the top of the rail | A saw kerf or routed groove |
| Movement allowed | As long as the slot | Limited, a few millimetres of rotation | Generous, along the groove |
| Best for | Steel bases, the usual answer for a slab | Narrow tops, small tables | Wooden aprons and frames |
| Weak point | Over-tightened screws defeat the slot | Not much travel on a wide top | Needs a groove, so not for bare steel |
The most common failure is a slotted base where every screw has been done up tight. The slot is then irrelevant: friction holds the top as rigidly as a round hole. Tighten until firm, then back off a fraction so the top is held but can still move. A washer under the screw head spreads the load and helps it slide.
How to lay them out
Fix the top rigidly at one point and let everything else move relative to it. That point is normally the centre of the width, so the top expands equally both ways and the overhangs stay even.
- Centre fixing: one or two screws through round holes, on the centre line of the width.
- Everything outboard of that: slots running across the grain, that is, parallel to the direction the top moves.
- Slot length: at least double the movement you expect, so about 15 to 20 mm of travel on a wide top.
- Count: four to six fixings per rail on a dining table. More is not better; it just adds places to get it wrong.
The slot direction is the thing people get backwards. Slots must run across the width of the top, not along its length.
Figure-eight fasteners in detail
A steel figure of eight, recessed into the top of a rail with one screw into the rail and one into the underside of the top. As the top moves, the plate pivots. They are quick and tidy, and they only offer a few millimetres of travel, so they suit tops up to around 70 or 80 cm wide. On a 130 cm slab they will not keep up.
Z-clips in detail
A Z-shaped steel clip with one leg in a groove cut in the inside of an apron and the other screwed to the underside of the top. The clip slides along the groove. Travel is generous and installation is fast, but it needs a wooden apron with a groove, so it belongs on a frame rather than on the typical bare steel slab base.
What not to do
- No glue between a solid top and a base, anywhere, ever.
- No pocket screws through round holes along the length of a rail.
- No rigid cleat or batten screwed across the width of the underside. It is a guaranteed crack, and it is the most common cause described in a new crack has appeared: what now.
- No overtightening, which converts every method back into a rigid fixing.
Retrofitting
If you have a base with round holes, you can usually file or mill them into slots, or drill out the holes oversize and use a washer under the screw head. That is a real fix and takes half an hour. More detail in putting a slab on a base you already own and in the general method in attaching a slab top to a base.
Common questions
How do you attach a solid wood top so it can move?
Fix it rigidly at one point, usually the centre of the width, and use slotted holes, figure-eight fasteners or Z clips everywhere else so the top can get wider and narrower.
Which way should the slots run?
Across the width of the top, in the direction the wood moves. Slots running along the length do nothing.
How tight should the screws be in a slotted hole?
Firm, then backed off slightly so the top is held but the screw can still slide in the slot. A washer under the head helps. Over-tightening makes the slot useless.
Are figure-eight fasteners enough for a wide slab?
They allow only a few millimetres of travel, which suits tops up to around 70 to 80 cm. A wide slab wants slotted holes instead.