The Sanding Sequence for a Slab Top
Which grits to use, when to stop, and why going finer than the finish needs makes the colour worse.
Sanding a slab is the step that decides how the finish looks, and most of the mistakes go in the same two directions: skipping grits, and carrying on past the point where it helps.
The sequence
| Grit | Job | When to move on |
|---|---|---|
| 60 or 80 | Only after a router sled or heavy stock removal | Machining marks gone |
| 100 or 120 | The real starting point on a prepared slab | Previous scratches gone, surface even |
| 150 | Refining | Surface uniform under raking light |
| 180 | Normal stopping point for hardwax oil | Stop here unless the data sheet says otherwise |
| 220 | Only if the finish asks for it | Film finishes sometimes do |
Never skip more than one step. Going from 80 straight to 180 means spending twenty minutes at 180 trying to remove scratches that 120 would have taken off in three, and usually failing.
Why finer is not better
Hardwax oil works by soaking into the surface fibres. Sand to 320 and you burnish the surface closed, the oil cannot penetrate properly, and you get a thinner, patchier, paler result. On walnut this shows up as a top that never reaches the depth of colour you saw on the test offcut.
The product data sheet will state the grit it expects. Follow it. For most hardwax oils on a slab table that is 150 to 180.
Turn the room lights off and shine a work lamp almost flat across the surface. Every scratch, swirl and dip that will be invisible under a finish and glaringly obvious afterwards shows up immediately. Check at every grit, not at the end.
Technique
- Random orbit sander, moving steadily. Roughly 2 to 3 cm per second, overlapping each pass by half. Let the machine's weight do the work; pressing down makes swirls.
- Change the disc often. A worn disc burnishes instead of cutting and costs more in time than it saves in discs.
- Vacuum between every grit. One stray coarse grain dragged under a fine disc makes a scratch you will be chasing for an hour. Vacuum the slab, the sander, and the bench.
- Hand sand the final grit along the grain on the top face if you want the cleanest result. It removes the last of the orbital swirl.
- Do the edges and the underside too, at least to a grit where they feel good, because they are getting finished as well.
The live edge
Do not take a power sander to a natural edge unless you intend to destroy its texture. Hand work with abrasive pads, a brass brush, and patience. The approach is in finishing the live edge itself.
Resin fills sand differently
Cured resin is harder than the wood around it. A soft pad dishes the timber and leaves the fill proud. Use a hard backing pad or a card scraper to take a fill flush, then blend with the rest of the top. See filling voids and knots with resin.
Water popping, and when it helps
Wiping the surface with a damp cloth after the final grit raises the grain deliberately, so you can cut it back once while the wood is bare rather than after the first coat of finish. It is optional on an oiled top, where a de-nib after coat one does the same job, and more useful under a film finish. The mechanism is in raised grain after the first coat.
Dust
A slab generates a serious amount of fine dust, and walnut dust in particular irritates. Extraction on the sander, a mask, and a room you can afterwards clean. Doing this indoors without extraction coats the whole house.
Common questions
What grit should I sand a table to before oiling?
Usually 150 to 180 for a hardwax oil. Check the product data sheet, because sanding finer closes the surface and the oil penetrates less.
Can I skip grits when sanding a slab?
Skipping one step is acceptable, skipping two is not. Each grit exists to remove the scratches of the one before, and a fine disc removes coarse scratches very slowly.
Why does my sanded slab have swirl marks?
Usually a worn disc, too much downward pressure, or moving the sander too fast. Check under raking light at every grit rather than at the end.
Should I sand the underside of a slab?
Yes, enough that it can be finished. The underside gets the same number of coats as the top, otherwise the two faces exchange moisture at different rates and the top cups.