Cross-Cut Rounds as Side Tables
Cookies are cut across the trunk, so they move and check differently. How to use one and what to accept.
A cookie is a slice cut across the trunk rather than along it. You get a round or oval piece with the growth rings as concentric circles and bark all the way around the edge. They make beautiful side tables and stools, and they behave completely differently from a lengthwise slab.
Anyone who tells you a cookie is just a round slab has not dried one.
Why cookies crack, and why it is not a defect
Wood shrinks as it dries, and it shrinks unevenly. It shrinks roughly twice as much around the growth rings (tangentially) as it does from the centre outward (radially).
On a lengthwise slab that difference causes cupping, which is manageable. On a cookie, where the rings are complete circles, it means the circumference is trying to shrink twice as fast as the radius can allow. Something has to give, and what gives is the wood: it splits radially, from the outside toward the pith.
So on almost every cookie you will see one or more radial checks running in from the edge. This is physics, not poor drying. A cookie with no checks at all is either very small, very slowly dried, or stabilised.
What that means when you buy one
You are choosing which compromise you want:
- Accept the check as the feature. Leave it, finish it, let it be the thing that tells you the table was a tree. It may open and close slightly with the seasons.
- Fill it. Resin, usually black or clear, poured into the check. Visually strong, and the fill does not move while the wood does, so a filled check can crack at its edges later.
- Bridge it. Butterfly keys across the check on the underside or both faces, which hold it from widening. See butterfly keys and crack repair.
- Cut it out. Remove a wedge and close the circle, which turns the round into a slightly smaller round. A lot of work and it changes the shape.
The honest advice: buy a cookie whose checks you already like the look of, rather than a cookie you plan to make perfect.
The pith is the other issue
The centre of the trunk, the pith, is the least stable part of any tree. It is often soft, sometimes rotten, and it is the point all the radial checks run toward.
When you look at a cookie, look at the middle:
- If the pith is sound and tight, you have a straightforward piece.
- If it is soft or there is a small void, it needs stabilising or filling, and it is where a split will start if one is going to.
Where cookies work
Their geometry decides their use. A cookie is typically 70 to 110 cm across and 6 to 7 cm thick, which is:
| Piece | Why it works |
|---|---|
| Side table | The natural size. 45 to 55 cm high beside a sofa or a bed. |
| Stool or low seat | Thick enough to sit on at 40 to 45 cm high. The round shape suits it. |
| Small coffee table | At 100 cm plus across, a single cookie is a complete low table. |
| Plant stand or pedestal | Where its instability matters least. |
| Dining table | Not from a cookie. The movement and checking across a large round make it the wrong start. Cut a round from a lengthwise slab instead: round or rectangular from a slab. |
Finishing a cookie: both faces, equally
This matters more on a cookie than on anything else, because the end grain is exposed across the entire top and bottom face.
End grain absorbs and releases moisture many times faster than side grain. A cookie finished on top and left bare underneath will take up moisture from below, swell on one face and cup, and the checks will move with it.
- Finish both faces and the bark edge to the same standard.
- Expect the end grain to drink far more finish than you are used to. The first coat will largely disappear.
- Let it stabilise indoors before finishing if it has been stored cold. See acclimatising a slab after delivery.
The bark edge
On a cookie the bark runs the full perimeter, which is most of what you see. Walnut bark is reasonably well attached but it is not permanent.
Decide early:
- Keep it, and stabilise it with a penetrating resin, accepting that pieces may come off eventually.
- Remove it down to the cambium layer, which gives a smooth, often lighter edge that many people prefer and which is far more durable.
K-01 at 110 by 80 to 110 cm and 7 cm thick, K-02 at 90 by 70 to 90 cm and 7 cm, K-03 at 95 by 80 to 95 cm and 6 cm. All walnut, kiln dried, supplied rough sawn. Prices per piece, without VAT.
Common questions
Will the crack get worse in my house?
It will move with the seasons, opening in a dry heated winter and closing in a humid summer. How much depends on your indoor humidity. Keeping the room stable is the single biggest factor: seasonal movement and humidity.
Can a cookie be flattened like a slab?
Yes, and it is more likely to need it, because cookies cup as they dry. Flattening removes thickness, so start thicker than the finished dimension you want.
Is a cookie cheaper than a slab?
Per piece, usually, because it is small. Per square metre it is not necessarily cheaper, because the waste and the drying losses are higher.
Can I use a cookie as a chopping board?
End grain is traditionally good for chopping boards, but the checks, the bark edge and the size make a cookie a poor one. Butcher's blocks are made of many small end-grain pieces glued together, which is a different construction.