A Plane Slab Bench and Where It Suits
Plane benches for entrances and window seats, including the thickness that keeps a long bench stiff.
The job plane does better than walnut or oak is the long bench: a window seat, a bench along a wall in a hall, a run of seating in a kitchen. Plane slabs in stock go to 330 cm, longer than either of the other species, and at a lower price per metre.
Height and span rules are shared across species and are in the walnut bench piece. This covers what plane changes.
Long benches need thickness, not luck
A 330 cm bench is a structure. The load case is people sitting anywhere along it, including exactly in the middle between supports, and the deflection you can accept on a bench is much smaller than on a table because you can feel it.
At 6 cm, which is what most of our plane is, the sensible approach for a long bench:
- Three supports, not two. Legs at roughly 40 cm in from each end plus one in the centre keeps each span near 120 cm, which 6 cm plane handles without complaint.
- Or a steel flat bar let into the underside, running the length, if you want the clean look of two supports. 50 by 8 mm steel in a routed channel transforms the stiffness.
- Do not use the 5 cm slab for a long unsupported bench. P-18 at 5 cm is a fine 120 cm bench and the wrong choice at 250 cm.
Why thickness matters so much is in how far a slab can span unsupported: stiffness scales with thickness cubed, so a centimetre is worth far more than it looks.
Window seats and sunlight
A window seat gets the most direct UV of any surface in a house, and it gets it unevenly, because part of it sits in the shadow of the reveal.
Plane is the best of the three species here, and it is a relative advantage rather than an absolute one:
- Walnut lightens under strong sun, so the sunlit part of a walnut window seat pales against the shaded part. Walnut shows this most.
- Oak ambers, warming toward honey where the light falls.
- Plane shifts least of the three, warming slightly. On a pale wood the change is also less visible, because the starting colour is closer to where it is going.
None of them is immune. A finish with UV inhibitors slows all three, and moving cushions around during the first year prevents a hard line.
A window seat is a heat trap
This is the practical problem with the location, and it has nothing to do with species. Behind a window, above a radiator, is the driest air in the house in winter and the hottest surface in summer.
What that does:
- The underside, facing a radiator, dries faster than the top face, which cups the board.
- Seasonal movement across the depth is larger than the same board elsewhere in the house.
The responses: finish both faces equally and thoroughly, leave an air gap below rather than boxing it in tight, and fix it so it can move across its depth. See seasonal movement and humidity and attaching a slab top to a base.
Plane on a seat: softness and the edge
Plane is softer than oak. On a seat that means two things:
- It is comfortable and warm, and it does not feel as hard through clothing as oak.
- The front edge needs a bigger radius than you would give oak, because a soft wood chips at a sharp arris and because the edge takes the wear.
Give the front edge 12 to 15 mm of radius and sand it finer than the rest of the piece. It is the part people touch constantly.
P-15 and P-17 at 330 cm, P-16 at 295 cm, P-18 at 240 cm by 115 to 125 cm at 5 cm thick, and a bookmatched pair P-19 and P-20. Kiln dried to 8 to 10 percent, supplied rough sawn.
Common questions
How deep should a window seat be?
40 to 45 cm to sit on properly with your back against cushions. Below 35 cm it is a ledge. Check the depth of the reveal before buying, because the seat usually has to fit inside it.
Can a plane bench go in a hallway?
Yes, with a well-maintained finish. It marks more readily than oak and shows marks more readily because it is pale. If the hall is rough, see oak benches.
Does spalting weaken a bench seat?
Sound spalting does not. Punky spalting, where the wood compresses under a fingernail, does, and it has no place in a structural seat. Ask about any spalted area before buying.